An Evaluation of the Productivity of the Native American 'Three Sisters' Agriculture System in Northern Wisconsin

File(s)
Date
2007-08Author
Martinez, Rhea Trotman
Publisher
University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point, College of Natural Resources
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Traditional agriculture systems were once common practice among Native
Americans, who produced crops without the addition of synthetic fertilizers and
pesticides. Incorporation of Native American cropping practices may be an effective
strategy in the development of modern sustainable and organic gardens. Reintroduction
of these garden systems into Native American communities may also help increase
nutrition and preserve cultural traditions. The Three Sisters garden combines corn, beans
and squash, three vegetables that appear to symbiotically benefit each other, thus
reducing the need for fertilizers, herbicides, pesticides, irrigation and weeding. Although
there are several accounts of the benefits of the Three Sisters approach in popular
gardening literature, no scientific studies documenting the effectiveness of the system
were found in published, peer-reviewed literature at the time of this study.
Through meetings and discussions with members of the Bad River and Red Cliff
tribal communities of Lake Superior Ojibwe in Northern Wisconsin held during the
summer and fall of 2005, the interests and needs of the these communities were assessed.
During this time, the communities expressed a desire to implement sustainable
agricultural systems, particularly reinstatement of the Three Sisters. Before promoting
the system, however, there was a need to further investigate its potential productivity.
This study took place at the Northern Great Lakes Visitor Center and at the Bad
River community gardens in Ashland County, WI during the 2006-cropping season. The
Three Sisters system was compared to monoculture plantations of corn, bean and squash
in terms of soil temperatures, gravimetric soil moisture content, weed cover, pest and
disease damage, adverse weather damage and crop yields (yield per plant and calories per
acre). The heirloom crops used were analyzed for nutritional data and compared to
conventional varieties. Soil samples were collected from each plot before planting and
again the following spring, and changes in total soil nitrogen levels were determined.
Benefits of the Three Sisters system included increased soil drainage, a reduction
in raccoon damage, and a higher yield in calories per acre. Increased soil temperatures in
early stages of crop development and decreased soil temperatures in later stages of
growth were also observed in Three Sisters treatments. Weed cover in Three Sisters
treatments was lower than in monoculture corn and bean treatments, but this difference
was only significant for monoculture beans at the Bad River site. More damage to corn
plants resulting from adverse weather was observed in monoculture treatments than in
Three Sisters treatments; however this difference was not statistically significant. The
heirloom crops used (rattlesnake pole bean and Hopi orange squash) were higher in
certain nutrients than conventional varieties.
No significant difference in the number of cucumber beetles on squash plants and
damage caused by corn smut and corn earworm on corn plants was noted between
monoculture and Three Sisters treatments. Yield per plant was not significantly greater
in Three Sisters treatments than in monoculture treatments. There was also no significant
difference in changes in total soil nitrogen between treatments from 2006-2007.
Permanent Link
http://digital.library.wisc.edu/1793/81177Type
Thesis