Wild Juvenile Salmonid Abundance and Outmigration in Wisconsin Tributaries to Lake Michigan

File(s)
Date
2018-05Author
Wegleitner, Eric J.
Publisher
University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point, College of Natural Resources
Metadata
Show full item recordPermanent Link
http://digital.library.wisc.edu/1793/80156Type
Thesis
Description
Executive Summary: Introduced salmonids (i.e., Chinook Oncorhynchus tshawytscha and Coho Salmon
Oncorhynchus kisutch, Rainbow Trout Oncorhynchus mykiss and Brown Trout Salmo trutta)
support important recreational fisheries within the Lake Michigan ecosystem. Historically, these
fisheries were thought to be primarily supported by stocking, but recent research indicates that
the majority of some salmonid species may be naturally reproduced. Natural reproduction of
salmonids is common and well researched in Michigan tributaries to Lake Michigan. Successful
salmonid reproduction is known to occur within some Wisconsin tributaries to Lake Michigan,
but little is known regarding the abundance and outmigration of fish hatching in these streams.
Specifically, anadromous Rainbow Trout (i.e., steelhead) stocked into Lake Michigan are known
to exhibit an adfluvial life history, migrating up tributaries to spawn. Wild offspring have been
collected in some of these tributaries, but whether these fish successfully outmigrate from these
streams into larger tributaries or Lake Michigan remains unknown. The objectives of my
research were to determine if: 1) abundance of wild juvenile salmonids (primarily steelhead)
varied among selected streams in relation to available spawning and age-0 habitat, 2) wild
juvenile salmonids successfully outmigrated from Wisconsin tributaries into Lake Michigan or
into larger tributaries, and 3) stream temperature regimes could limit survival of juvenile
salmonids in these streams.
Six streams considered to have high to moderate potential (relative to other Wisconsin
tributaries) for steelhead natural reproduction were selected for my research in consultation with
biologists from the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. Four of these streams (Fischer,
Hibbard, Stony, and Sauk creeks) are tributaries to Lake Michigan and two of the streams
(Pigeon and Willow creeks) are tributaries to the Milwaukee and Sheboygan rivers that flow
directly into Lake Michigan. Abundance of naturally-reproduced steelhead and Coho Salmon in
each stream was estimated by multiple-pass depletion methods using backpack electrofishing
equipment. Average abundance among electrofishing transects was extrapolated to stream length
to calculate population size for each stream. Habitat assessments included steelhead redd surveys
in spring 2017 and age-0 habitat surveys in summer 2017. Passive integrated transponders (PIT)
were implanted in juvenile salmonids and PIT tag monitoring systems were constructed at the
mouth of 3 of 6 streams (Willow, Stony, and Hibbard creeks) to determine rates of outmigration
during fall 2016 and spring through fall of 2017. Temperature data were collected using
temperature loggers placed at multiple locations in each stream.
Population estimates for individual streams ranged from 84-2,528 juvenile (age-0 and
age-1+) steelhead and 0-801 juvenile Coho Salmon. There was not a correlation between redd
counts or availability of suitable age-0 habitat and juvenile steelhead abundance. Outmigration
was rarely detected on all three monitored streams with outmigration rates ranging from 1.4%
2.9% among streams. Stream temperature rarely or never exceeded the acute thermal limit for
steelhead (27°C) among streams. Additionally, stream temperature did not exceed the chronic
thermal limit for steelhead (24°C) for long enough periods to be of concern.
My results indicate that outmigration of wild juvenile steelhead and Coho Salmon from
Wisconsin tributaries to Lake Michigan is minimal, although I was not able to determine
outmigration rates during winter months. Moreover, abundance of wild juvenile steelhead and
Coho Salmon in Wisconsin tributaries to Lake Michigan is generally low (hundreds to thousands
of fish compared to hundreds of thousands of fish produced in many Michigan streams). Relative
to the total numbers of fish stocked and wild age-0 abundance in Michigan tributaries, the
contribution of wild juvenile steelhead and Coho Salmon from Wisconsin tributaries to adult populations in Lake Michigan is likely minimal. Return of wild steelhead produced in these
streams is probably insufficient to maintain fisheries within these streams. Lack of suitable
habitat could contribute to relatively low abundance in Wisconsin streams. Large-scale
watershed improvement projects may be effective for increasing the amount of suitable habitat,
but increases in juvenile salmonid abundance would likely be inconsequential on a lake wide
level.