Study of the difference in coverage of the Israeli operation in Gaza (December, 2008 to January, 2009) in the New York Times and BBC
MetadataShow full item record
Coverage of the Middle East by western media is often an issue of argument. The most controversial is how this media cover the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While media defend itself by claiming the balanced, objective coverage, and being equally distanced from both sides, it is criticized by both the pro Palestinian and pro Israeli audiences for being sympathetic with one side or the other, like the idea of being a part of a western unfairness to the Middle Eastern conflict (Said, 1997, Fish, 2004) This study is a textual analysis of New York Times and British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) coverage of war Israel initiated in Gaza between December 27th, 2008 and January 17th, 2009. These two western media can be seen as different organizations in their structure, relation with the governments, and editorial policies. Stories published in their electronic version www.bbc.co.uk and www.nytimes.com were analyzed by applying Merrill?s (1968) model to the sources used in this coverage, and information quoted from these sources. Analysis included five categories: sources, specificity in naming these sources, and specificity in reporting casualties when reported by such sources. The analysis found differences in the use of sources between these two western media in covering the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but maintaining that both NYT and BBC tend to use Israeli more than Palestinian sources, with NYT heavily relying on more Israeli sources, and BBC using closer to an equal number of sources from both sides. Results of in inequality of number of sources used by media can also relate to the differences in which the Israel and the Palestinians have dealt with the media, and the availability of personnel and information on both sides, which can make an excuse for media to use sources of one side more than the other.
Gaza War, 2008-2009--Press coverage
Gaza Strip--Press coverage
Arab-Israeli conflict--Press coverage
Broadcast journalism--Great Britain
New York Times Company
British Broadcasting Corporation
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ok, Chang Bong; Han, Hyeyoung (2009-02-06)The media in North Karea are closely tied to ther communist sociopolitical structures. Therefore, news in North Korea has always been shown at the representation of the political ideology and interest of the communist ...
Busacker, Kristin (2010-04)This study uses a controversial foreign policy issue named the Six-party talks on nuclear issues. There is little known of how western media have covered the North Korean issues and how they may interpret this controversial ...
Hathaway, Steven (2011-05-10)At the beginning of the 20th century, the world dissolved into chaos in the form of the First World War. Being the first truly modern war, military doctrine and strategy were not able to comprehend the newly acquired ...